It's all very well giving SFA flunkies George Peat and Gordon Smith a portion of the blame, but at the end of the day it was Burley who failed to produce the goods, Burley who failed to inspire his players (all 52 of them) to consistency, Burley who presided over some of the most mediocre performances in recent times, and Burley who managed to alienate not only his own players, but perhaps more crucially the support of the Tartan Army and the nation.
The time has come to make a change at the helm and begin the rebuilding process started by Walter Smith and continued so well by Alex McLeish following the shambles of the Vogts era. We don't expect an announcement soon, but some candidates have already been named by the media. We take a look at the possibilities.
The Candidates
Craig Levein, the current Dundee United manager would make an excellent choice given the amazing results he's getting at Tannadice, but he's just maneuvererd himself into a position where he can shape the club according to his own vision. He's overhauled the youth setup and has his team playing decent football. He's close to the Thomson family, who will be very unlikely and unwilling to let him go. He's not keen on Gordon Smith either, and he's expressed a desire to return south someday.
Nottingham Forest manager Billie Davies is another possibility, though with Forest currently 2 points from the play-off places in the Championship, he'll be reluctant to make the move north.
Former Aberdeen legend Billy Stark has been showing the way forward with the U21's and has club management experience, but would he want to step up to the pressure of life with the big boys?
Darren Ferguson, son of Alex Ferguson is available following his departure from Peterborough United whom he'd led through back-to-back promotion from League Two to the Championship. He might well want to get back into contention for the Manchester United job, a job he´s been linked with as a possible future successor to his father, and what better way than to take a bunch of no-hopers and lead them to a major European competition - it´d certainly get you noticed. A somewhat checkered personal life may well attract the wrong kind of media attention however ...
Walter Smith may well be looking for a job in January if promises of additional funds are not forthcoming at Rangers. Then again, would he be looking for this job? He's done it before, so the job probably holds little challenge for him and let's face it, the nation has never forgiven him for walking out on the job to return to club management.
Ally McCoist, Smith's assistant at Ibrox might also be a victim in the upcoming shake-up at Ibrox. Comfortable with the media, he's a pundits choice. He´s also served time in the trenches before for Scotland alongside Walter Smith, but he lacks the experience needed to take the job on full-time.
Jim Jefferies must be getting pretty bored at Kilmarnock these days, and the challenges of the Scotland job, together with the easier pace of life the job affords may just be the ticket for a man who has no club management ambitions once his contract at Killie is up. Like Walter Smith, Jefferies has been around the block (twice) and knows many of the players and crucially might be the man to bring his former star Kris Boyd back to the fold.
Aberdeen manager Mark McGhee might well be tempted away from his misfiring adventures in the north-east. Interviewed for the Scotland job already, he´s not exactly been setting the heather alight at Pittodrie so far, but who can blame him with the "talent" and budget available to him. The Aberdeen board might welcome the compensation the SFA would need to pay to entice the former Aberdeen and Celtic striker away, so for a small sum, possibly in the low-to-mid hundreds given the state of Aberdeen´s finances, you might have a candidate with a good eye for young talent, but not in a Gary Glitter way, obviously.
Joe Jordan. He's Scottish and a legend, so he'd be popular with the support. But former legends do not always make good managers, and besides, he´s a little like Carlos Quiroz - a good number 2, but can he do the job on his own?
The "Fuck No" List
Graeme Souness. I'd rather have Vogts back than this moustache-wearing cunt, an odious man whose gone through more clubs than Dean Windass. Souness, a self confessed mercenary who was only ever in it for the money has the staying power of a stale fart and the personality to match. His appointment would certainly bring some order and discipline to the squad, but at what price?
Terry Butcher, another of the former Rangers contingent associated with Souness, Butcher is a great motivator, but a thoroughly mediocre manager (although mediocrity is not something that's seen as a deal-breaker at SFA HQ). Besides, he's English.
So aye, who would you lot like as manager? Answers in a comment down below please.
Next? Lol implying theres a queue of willing candidates.
ReplyDeleteI would like to see Levein, as he always seems to get a lot from his players. But will the SFA spend money? I doubt it. I think you may see someone like McAllister (hope not) as he is unemployed ie cheap! Maybe Darren Ferguson has been tipped off and thats why he left, and hes bringing his dad as part time adviser! Aye I'll wake up now! I think it'll be McAllister as he won't cost. I would like Levein or even Jeffries.
Pity we didn't sack him a wee while ago and we could be asking Strachan.
Ach well, maybe they'll pull a rabbit out the sporran. Here's hoping.
Levein would be good, though i´d doubt he´d take it. In fact, I doubt many of the people in this list would take it. Jefferies might, and I think he´d have the authority and respect to make a decent job.
ReplyDeleteI like your Darren Ferguson theory by the way, never thought of that.
Agreed - Levein won't take the job. McCoist might not be the worst thing. I'd take almost anyone over Smith again.
ReplyDeleteMcGhee has stated in his column in the local paper in Aberdeen today that he will not be applying.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if Levein may be tempted as with the financial constraints he may have taken his current club as far as it can go?
Calderwood has also been mentioned and interviewed today said that he'd be up for it if considered. Then again, as I said in a text to a colleague who suggested this last nigh, "I'M a fat useless c***, but a cheaper fat usesless c*** than that fat useless c***. I REALLY REALLY REALLY don't have issues with the fat useless c***. None at all.
Strange that nobody's mentioned the multi-talented tactical and motivational genius that is Alex Smith. Aberdeen fans are still being pilloried by eejits like Chick Young for hastening his departure in 1992. I look forward to St Mirren's Most Famous Fan (aye, right) lobbying on Smith's behlaf.
I agree with your "fuck no" list and would add Jefferies to it.
Alex Smith - is he not a bit too old? He's pushing 70.
ReplyDeleteAnd McGhee's not applying? Shite. How about getting Willie Miller to apply? Either one to feck off, I'll be happy.
Calderwood might be an interesting choice. With his "formation wheel of fortune" he used so well at Pittodrie he would certainly have the opposition guessing, but he's actually a much better manager than people give him credit for - he might not do a bad job.
I actually think Jefferies might be a good choice. He's older (and therefore experienced), has no lofty ambitions to manage anywhere else so he'd be there for the long haul. He's not exactly a personality tour-de-force, but we don't need an X-Factor contestant, just someone who can pull a team together and restore some credibility.
Hey, what's Kenny Dalglish up to these days?
Tuesday Links: van Persie’s unusual ankle treatment, Garber on Montreal expansion...
ReplyDeleteWorld Cup Qualifying + Lassana Diarra has denied triggering the mass confrontation which marred...
[...] start, this site never believed he had much of a future, so when the axe finally fell on his reign, we where happy enough to wave him off. Our disappointment was not so much for the man, but more for the long drawn-out lingering death of [...]
ReplyDelete